Customer Favorites Revealed: The 10 Most-Loved Pizzas at Pizzawala’s
A Slice of Popularity: How We Chose the Best of the Best
When it comes to pizza, everyone has a favorite. But what happens when you gather reviews, online ratings, order histories, and customer feedback across multiple cities? You get a deliciously definitive list of Pizzawala’s best-selling pizzas, the ones people can’t stop ordering, snapping, and raving about. From the heat-seekers to the comfort-food lovers, we’re breaking down the best pizzas to order at Pizzawala’s to help first-timers and loyal fans alike make their next order the most crave-worthy yet.
So whether you’re in the mood to try something new or you’re looking for the most popular pizza in Des Plaines, Columbus, or Canton, this list is your ultimate pizza compass.
The 10 Most-Loved Pizzas at Pizzawala’s
Paneer Tikka Pizza – The Spicy Vegetarian Icon
Flavor Profile: Chargrilled paneer tikka, spiced tomato sauce, fresh bell peppers, onions, and gooey mozzarella.
Why Customers Love It: It’s the perfect balance of creamy and spicy, a true desi delight on a pizza base. This one flies out of the oven in record numbers.
Popular At: Consistently loved across all Pizzawala’s locations.
Butter Paneer Pizza – The Creamy Comfort Bite
Flavor Profile: A luscious makhani (butter) sauce base topped with paneer, creamy cheese, and light Indian spices.
Why Customers Love It: Think of your favorite butter paneer curry, now imagine it melted into a cheesy pizza. Pure comfort food heaven.
Popular At: A major favorite in Columbus and Canton.
Chili Paneer Pizza – Bold, Tangy, and Addictive
Flavor Profile: Sweet and spicy Indo-Chinese-style chili paneer, peppers, and onions over mozzarella and chili garlic sauce.
Why Customers Love It: A fiery mix of flavors with a satisfying crunch. Spice lovers call it their ‘weekly fix.’
Popular At: One of the most popular pizzas in Canton.
Garlic Chicken Pizza – The Flavor Bomb
Flavor Profile: Savory garlic-marinated chicken, herbed sauce, onions, and roasted garlic chunks.
Why Customers Love It: Packed with punchy garlic flavor and tender chicken, this pizza keeps carnivores coming back.
Popular At: Especially adored in Des Plaines and Canton.
Achari Paneer Pizza – Zing with Every Bite
Flavor Profile: Paneer tossed in tangy achari masala, paired with peppers, onions, and a hint of chili.
Why Customers Love It: It’s bold. It’s tangy. It tastes like your favorite Indian pickle met pizza and they fell in love.
Popular At: Trending in Canton and Columbus for its unique flavor.
Cheese Pizza – The Classic Crowd-Pleaser
Flavor Profile: A golden crust topped with signature tomato sauce and a rich blend of cheeses.
Why Customers Love It: It’s simple, nostalgic, and oh-so-satisfying. A guaranteed hit with kids and purists alike.
Popular At: A consistent chart-topper across Des Plaines, Columbus, and Canton.
Chicken Tikka Pizza – The Bold Carnivore’s Dream
Flavor Profile: Tandoori-marinated chicken, onions, peppers, and a masala sauce blend.
Why Customers Love It: It brings the tandoor to your table with tender chicken and rich Indian spices.
Popular At: Consistently loved across all Pizzawala’s locations.
A hit in Des Plaines and a go-to in Michigan.
Butter Chicken Pizza – Sweet, Savory & Saucy
Flavor Profile: Creamy butter chicken sauce with tandoori chicken chunks, onions, and cheese.
Why Customers Love It: It’s indulgent, rich, and an epic twist on the beloved curry.
Popular At: Extremely popular in Columbus and Canton.
Chatpata Veg Pizza – Tangy, Crunchy, Totally Addictive
Flavor Profile: A mix of tangy chutneys, crisp vegetables, masalas, and sev on top of cheese.
Why Customers Love It: It’s fun, flavorful, and packs a crunchy punch. This one’s for those who love street-food vibes.
Popular At: Beloved in Canton and rising in Columbus.
Gobi Manchurian Pizza – The Unexpected Winner
Flavor Profile: Spicy, saucy cauliflower Manchurian bites paired with mozzarella and zesty toppings.
Why Customers Love It: It’s a surprise hit that even non-vegetarians rave about. Bold, saucy, and totally unique.
Popular At: A strong contender in Canton and Columbus.
Honorable Mentions – Just Missed the Top 10!
While the top 10 pizzas hold a special place in our hearts (and stomachs), a few others came very close:
- Meat-a-more Pizza – For those who like it loaded
- BBQ Chicken Pizza – Smoky, tangy, and beloved by many
- Mango Paneer Pizza – A bold fusion of creamy paneer and tangy-sweet mango
- Classic Veggie Pizza – A timeless mix of peppers, olives, and onions
Next time you’re browsing the menu, don’t skip these underrated gems!
Your Pizza Discovery Guide
If you’re a first-time customer, we hope this list makes ordering easier (and tastier). If you’re a returning fan, maybe it’s time to try that Achari Paneer or Gobi Manchurian you’ve been eyeing. And for families and groups, use this as your cheat sheet for the best pizzas to order at Pizzawala’s.
Because when it comes to pizza, playing favorites is more than allowed, it’s encouraged.
FAQs
The top 10 pizzas include Paneer Tikka, Butter Chicken, Chili Paneer, Garlic Chicken, and more, all picked from real customer orders and feedback.
Pizzawala’s offers a bold Indian twist on classic pizzas, using globally loved flavors like tikka, Manchurian, and achari in an all-American pizza format.
Absolutely! Our menu features a wide variety of vegetarian favorites like Paneer Tikka, Achari Paneer, Gobi Manchurian, and more.
Yes! We love letting our customers build their dream pizza. Choose your crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings to make it your own.
From Des Plaines to Michigan to Columbus, the love for these pizzas is loud, proud, and ever-growing. And if you haven’t tried them yet, now’s the perfect time to discover what all the hype is about. After all, great pizza isn’t just food, it’s a vibe.
Hungry yet? Come grab a slice at Pizzawala’s, where bold flavors meet beloved classics.
About Author
At Pizzawala’s, we bring decades of expertise in crafting fusion pizzas that blend craftsmanship with bold, unique flavors. Our commitment to using fresh, high-quality ingredients ensures that every bite is delicious and memorable. Loved by pizza enthusiasts worldwide, it delivers a wholesome experience in every meal.
Follow the Expert
